Prepare your taste buds for a journey of delight as the Bedford Tribune unveils a culinary gem: the renowned Secret Herb Mustard Recipe. For many years, this proprietary recipe was used as a fund raiser for the historic Bedford Garden Club. Sadly, the Garden Club was forced to stop selling the mustard as changes in State food preparation laws made it more difficult to make and sell small batch products like this from a home kitchen. But you can now make this Bedford classic in your own home kitchen! After careful sleuthing and tireless pursuit, we are thrilled to share this coveted recipe with you, straight from the heart of our community.

Bedford Garden Club Mustard Ingredients:

Original Bulk Recipe

  • 1 gallon Mustard (French’s)
  • 2 lbs. Dark brown sugar
  • 8 Tbsp. Lemon thyme
  • 8 Tsp. Dried marjoram
  • 8 Tsp. Dried basil
  • 8 Tsp. Ground coriander seed
  • 2 Tsp. Celery seed
  • 6 cups Miracle Whip

Bulk & Home Recipes

Home Recipe

2 Cups Mustard (French’s)
1/4 lbs. Dark brown sugar
1 Tbsp. Lemon thyme
1 Tsp. Dried marjoram
1 Tsp. Dried basil
1 Tsp. Ground coriander seed
1/4 Tsp. Celery seed
3/4 cups Miracle Whip

Directions:

  1. Add sugar to mustard until sugar is dissolved.
  2. Grind dried herbs and celery seed until powdered.
  3. Add herbs to mustard, stir in well.
  4. Add Miracle Whip and mix thoroughly.
  5. Return to gallon jar plus extra in another jar.
  6. Keep refrigerated.
  7. Age for two weeks.

With each dollop of this Secret Herb Mustard, you’re not just indulging in a condiment; you’re savoring a piece of Bedford’s culinary heritage. We encourage you to share this recipe with friends and family, spreading the joy of flavor far and wide.

Stay tuned to the Bedford Tribune for more hidden treasures and community delights!